Health & movement

Historical ideal body weight formula comparison

Compare Devine and Hamwi height-based formulas with separate general adult BMI boundary weights.

Your numbers

Calculated on your device. Your inputs aren’t sent to us.

Your result

Ready when you are

Enter your inputs and select Calculate.

Report an issue

Try it, understand it

Explore the result

Compare the stated assumptions using these worked scenarios.

Worked example comparison
ExampleOutputWhat to notice
Two historical formulasSelected historical formula73 kgAt 70 inches, male Devine gives 73 kg.
Highlight HamwiSelected historical formula75.296333 kgThe same height gives 166 lb or 75.29633342 kg.
Below the reference heightSelected historical formulaNot displayed below the five-foot reference heightHistorical outputs are withheld; BMI boundary arithmetic remains.

Check your understanding

Why can Devine and Hamwi disagree?

Their bases, increments and original units differ.

Why are the historical outputs withheld below 152.4 cm?

This tool does not extrapolate those formulas below their five-foot reference.

Behind the numbers

How this calculation works

Convert height to inches and subtract the five-foot reference. Devine adds 2.3 kg for each additional inch to its selected base. Hamwi uses 106 lb plus 6 lb per inch for male coefficients, or 100 lb plus 5 lb for female coefficients. Separately multiply height in metres squared by BMI boundaries 18.5 and 25 to display general reference weights.

THE FORMULADevine: 50/45.5 kg + 2.3 kg per inch above five feet; Hamwi uses a different pound-based equation

A worked example

At 177.8 cm, height is 70 inches, ten inches above the reference. Devine male coefficients give 50+2.3×10 = 73 kg. Hamwi gives 166 lb, or 75.29633342 kg. These different formulas do not determine one uniquely ideal weight.

Good to know

Historical formulas are displayed only at heights of at least 152.4 cm. General BMI boundaries are not personalized healthy-weight targets, and the upper 25 boundary is exclusive. This tool is not suitable for medication dosing, pregnancy targets or pediatric growth assessment.

Historical formulas do not define one ideal person

Devine and Hamwi assign different base values and different increments above five feet. The same height can therefore produce two different outputs without either calculation containing an arithmetic error. Their historical names should not be read as proof that one exact weight is healthy or appropriate for every person of that height.

This page corrects the old confusion between the names and coefficients. Devine uses kilograms; Hamwi starts in pounds and is converted with the exact pound-to-kilogram factor. The height converter helps verify how many inches exceed the reference height before either increment is applied.

Keep formula comparison separate from BMI boundaries

The general adult BMI references are calculated independently as BMI times height in metres squared. The upper boundary is 25 and is exclusive for the interval ending below 25; a displayed boundary weight should not be described as an inclusive maximum. The BMI calculator provides the separate ratio for a given weight.

Below five feet, this tool withholds the historical formula values rather than extrapolating unsupported downward increments. It still shows the explicitly labeled general BMI boundary arithmetic. Pregnancy, age, composition and clinical circumstances complicate interpretation, so neither the formula comparison nor the reference interval is presented as a personal target or a medication-dose weight.

A few questions, answered

Why can Devine and Hamwi disagree?

Their bases, increments and original units differ.

Why are the historical outputs withheld below 152.4 cm?

This tool does not extrapolate those formulas below their five-foot reference.

Is the BMI 25 boundary included in a below-25 interval?

No. It is an exclusive upper boundary.

Find your calculator

Start typing to explore the library.